Defendant denied the claim and Walton commenced this action to recover his "basic economic loss," demanding the statutory cap of $50,000 (see, Insurance Law § 5102 ). Walton filed a claim for no-fault benefits. Walton employed the levelator as described and while he was standing on it with a load of dairy products the levelator tipped over, throwing him to the ground causing him to sustain injuries which required medical care and resulted in his losing time from work. He could then lower the levelator to the height of the loading dock and transport the goods from the levelator to the loading dock. A ramp was thus created that enabled him to transfer goods from the truck to the levelator. The supermarket provided an apparatus called a "levelator" to facilitate delivery and, after obtaining a control device from the supermarket, Walton raised the levelator to the same height as the truck bed and attached plates from the levelator to the truck. He backed his employer's tractor-trailer up to the supermarket's loading dock, got out of the truck and opened the rear cargo door. On the day he was injured he was delivering dairy products to a Grand Union supermarket in Niskayuna. Plaintiff William Walton was employed as a truck driver by Crowley Foods, Inc. We hold that where a person's injuries were produced by an instrumentality other than the vehicle itself, no-fault first-party benefits are not available. The sole issue before the Court is whether plaintiff's injuries arose out of the use or operation of the truck within the meaning of Insurance Law § 5102 (b). Plaintiff was injured while unloading a truck at a supermarket loading dock and sought no-fault benefits from defendant, *213 the insurer of the truck. Hutter of counsel), for respondent.Ĭhief Judge KAYE and Judges TITONE, BELLACOSA, SMITH and CIPARICK concur Judge LEVINE taking no part. Thuillez, Ford, Gold & Conolly, LLP, Albany (Michael J. Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Company, Respondent.Ĭourt of Appeals of the State of New York.īohl, Della Rocca & Dorfman, P.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |